In the 60 games played by New York (comprising the NY Magpies and Gotham Magpies) to October 20, 2002, 124 players have represented the club, with the club introducing 41 US and other non-Australians to the great game of Australian football. Note: Completeness and accuracy of player records prior to Game 34 have not been independently verified.

Paul ARMISTEAD, Shane BRADDOCK, Greg BRERETON, James BUSH, Ed CLANCY, Mark DIAMOND, Jim FERGUSON, Joel FREDMAN, Neil FOX, Gordy GAYFORD, Ian GAZARD, Rob GIABARDO, Adam GRABOW, Brad HOWES, Mal KENNARD, Charles KICKHAM, John LALOR, Ed LYNCH, Peter MASTOS, Mitch MORRISON, Blake MYLES, Steve NATION, Deon NEWMAN, Shane O’CALLAGHAN, Paul ODLUM, Matthew REID, Scott SARGEANT, Eric SCHATZ, Tony VALERI , Dave WALSH, Dave WEINBERGER , Shandar WOLKENSBURG, Daniel ZMOOD